Town - 2 Mayhew Lane

Town - 2 Mayhew Lane | Image #0
Town - 2 Mayhew Lane | Image #1
Town - 2 Mayhew Lane | Image #2
Town - 2 Mayhew Lane | Image #3
Town - 2 Mayhew Lane | Image #4

2 Mayhew Lane, Nantucket MA 02554

New Listing West of Town

Moments from upper Main Street is Mayhew Lane, conveniently located close to downtown, which provides quick access to South Shore beaches. With conservation land across the street, this attractive three-level home offers four bedrooms and three and a half baths with several areas for relaxing and entertaining. A one car garage with studio above completes the property. “While In Bhutan” is offered mostly furnished with bright, generously sized rooms features three fireplaces, wainscoting, moldings, built ins and many other custom details. Property offers timely occupancy or investment opportunities with a solid past rental history. For more information on Town, view our Neighborhood Guide!

First Floor

The front foyer with staircase offers a quiet, cozy living area to the right with fireplace. Beyond is a large spacious casual living/family room with fireplace, built-ins and French doors opening to the beautiful patio with ample dining space and grill. A spacious kitchen offers plenty of storage and is open to the dining area which seats 6-8 people. Large center island with eating area and modern appliances. Powder room, laundry room and side door access to parking and yard create the perfect place to relax.

Second Floor

Spacious ensuite primary bedroom with fireplace and large walk-in closet. Private bathroom with tiled shower, double sinks, and Jacuzzi Tub. Two comfortable twin bedrooms share a hall bath.

Third Floor

Large bedroom with private bath and shower. Removable ladder which provides access to the widow's walk.



Secondary Dwelling

One car garage. Private access to studio above with full bathroom located off the hall on the first floor. Mini Split AC system in Studio. Outdoor shower attached to garage.

$4,295,000 Asking price
9 Rooms
5 Bedrooms
5 Bathrooms
3269 Approx sq ft

Listed by Great Point Properties

Photo Gallery



Representation By

Michele Lindstedt avatar
Michele Lindstedt

Email: michele@greatpointproperties.com

Mobile: 508-737-0134

Some homes we are born in, and some homes we discover. Originally hailing from upstate New York, Michele first fell in love with Nantucket when she summered here in 1990. After graduating with a BFA in graphic design, Michele moved to Nantucket and met her husband, David. Over the next 20 years, Michele honed a career in advertising sales working for various Nantucket magazines, newspapers, a radio station, and a television station. Many locals know her as the former Director of Sales for Nantucket Magazine and Senior Account Executive for The Inquirer & Mirror Newspaper. After living and working on the island for 28 years, Michele joined Great Point Properties in 2014. Her in-depth knowledge of island life has naturally translated into a fruitful real estate career, a profession that allows Michele to do what she loves: helping people discover their home on Nantucket, just as she did many years ago.

Michele has gained a broader "island living" perspective after sailing throughout the Caribbean and the Bahamas for two seasons. In addition to sailing, Michele enjoys walking on the beach with her two border collies (Mojo and Casper), fishing, traveling, and spending time with family and friends. Together with her husband’s company Sankaty Light Property Management, they are involved with the Anglers Club, PASCON, NISHA, and various other non-profits on the island.

Carol Coffin avatar
Carol Coffin

Email: carol@greatpointproperties.com

Mobile: 508-560-2916

Carol was born and raised in Garden City, New York and was educated at Green Mountain College, Vermont, and Boston University. Carol has been married to Bernie Coffin since 1968 and they have two children. Carol has been a Massachusetts broker since 1978 and a Florida real estate agent since 1980. Carol began assisting Bernie at the Sconset Real Estate office which he owned after their marriage, and they have had a close relationship with the Village of Sconset for generations. In 2007 the Coffins renovated their Sconset Post Office Building and received the Nantucket Preservation Award. Carol and Bernie owned and managed Sconset Real Estate and Coffin Real Estate together full-time. In 2014 the Coffins choose to sell Sconset Real Estate to Great Point Properties, where Carol moved to work in the tow office. Her enjoyment from working with people and spending time with their family, including five grandchildren, are the focus of their time on Nantucket.  Carol continues to do referrals in Vero Beach, Florida, where they have also lived part-time since 1979. Outside of work, Carol enjoys some time playing bridge and mah Jongg.


Education: Garden City schools, AA Green Mountain College, VT & BS Boston University, MA

Professional Experience-  Owner/Broker Sconset Real Estate and Coffin Real Estate, sales associate Vero Beach, FL and Broker Great Point Properties Real Estate.  NAREB.

Affiliations: Past member of MA Association of Realtors, The Sankaty Golf and Beach Club,  The Siasconset Chapel, The Siasconset Casino, The Moorings Yacht and Country Club, Vero Beach, FL.  The Sconset Trust.

Charitable Organizations:  Sconset Trust, Siasconset Chapel, Nantucket Preservation Trust, Sconset Civic Association, Nantucket Historical Association, Hope For Families.

Request More Info

Please fill out the form below if you would like additional information or would like to schedule a viewing for Town - 2 Mayhew Lane

    Preferred Method of Communication

    Call Agent