33 Fair Street

33 Fair Street | Image #0
33 Fair Street | Image #1
33 Fair Street | Image #2
33 Fair Street | Image #3
33 Fair Street | Image #4
33 Fair Street | Image #5

33 Fair Street, Nantucket

3D Tour

Located on the corner of Darling and Fair Streets, the James Cartwright house, which was built in the late 18th century, was meticulously renovated in 1997. Boasting gracious and bright rooms the home has wonderful charm and allows for comfortable living. Spend warm summer days relaxing on the private brick patio. The driveway allows parking for two vehicles. A stone's throw from Main Street and the Harbor front it is the IDEAL In-Town property. This home has an excellent rental history with tenants commenting on how enjoyable their visit has been while staying at this delightful home.

First Floor:

From a spacious foyer, there is a front formal living room to the right and den/office to the left. A pass-thru butler's pantry with ice maker leads into the formal dining room. Windows and light surround the informal den, living room, and open gourmet kitchen. A short hallway off the kitchen leads to a powder room and back entry with porch.

Second Floor:

The hallway leads to two spacious and sunny bedrooms with custom shuttered windows. Continue down the hall to the splendid master suite which includes a separate sitting room or den. The master bathroom includes a generous closet with its own stacked washer and dryer.

Third Floor:

The large, open sitting room has a skylight and built-in beds. There is a bathroom with tiled shower. A separate bedroom has two built-in twin beds. There is a bonus room that makes a perfect playroom.


Re-inforced brick foundation with a poured cement floor, laundry area with washer & dryer. Interior and exterior staircases access the basement.


$ Selling price
12 Rooms
4 Bedrooms
3 Bathrooms
3200 Approx sq ft

Photo Gallery




Representation By

Debbi Deeley Culbertson avatar
Debbi Deeley Culbertson

Email: debbid@greatpointproperties.com

Mobile: 508-325-2021

Debbi, a native to Nantucket has 20 years of real estate experience on Nantucket. Debbi went to school off island where she focused her studies on architecture and took advantage of the time to travel abroad extensively. She spent 17 years in the ski industry, including developing and owning two stores in the Utah ski resorts along with designing and representing high end ski wear and goods. Each summer, Debbi would return to the island for an extended summer and moved back permanently in 1998. Having a keen sense for sales and an eye for design, she went directly into real estate as it felt like "a natural fit". She gets great satisfaction from combining her knowledge of architecture and extensive knowledge of the Island to help each client find their perfect home on Nantucket. Debbi and her husband, Peter, enjoy a number of summer and winter activities, including boating, skiing, horseback riding, and motorcycling. They share their home with three beagles, one lab/border collie mix, a wayward cat, a horse and two ponies.

Carl Lindvall avatar
Carl Lindvall

Email: carl@greatpointproperties.com

Mobile: 508-360-4323

As native of Nantucket, Carl enjoys all experiences that the island has to offer, including, fishing, surfing, boating, fine dining, cookouts and sunsets at the beach. Carl is a proud father of three children; two daughters, Virginia and Lilly, and son, Hutton. After attending school at Northfield Mount Hermon and college at the University of Colorado at Boulder, Carl returned to the island where he took on a career in fine dining and formal customer service. Nantucket is a specialty market that demands attention to detail, quick response, and local know-how in order to close a deal. Carl strives to be the best and to always be honest. Finding families the best fit for the best price is his passion.

Request More Info

Please fill out the form below if you would like additional information or would like to schedule a viewing for 33 Fair Street

Preferred Method of Communication

Call Agent