39A Milk Street Nantucket, MA 02554

West of Town

Overview
Property Details
Location

Contact Agent

$5,500,000

Asking Price

Off-market

Market Status

Bedrooms

5.1

Bathrooms

4,793

Square Footage

Welcome to 39A Milk Street Nantucket, a stunning five-bedroom, five-and-a-half-bathroom home that perfectly blends historic island charm with modern luxury. Spanning nearly 5,000 square feet, this exceptional property offers multiple living areas designed for both relaxation and entertaining, making it an ideal retreat for family and friends. Conveniently located near Main Street’s boutiques, restaurants, and cultural attractions, and just minutes from Nantucket’s South Shore beaches, this home provides the best of both worlds—privacy and proximity. The thoughtfully designed interiors feature transitional spaces that flow seamlessly, while the outdoor areas include a spacious deck, patio, and parking. The property abuts Nantucket Land Bank conservation land, ensuring lasting peace and privacy in the backyard. With the potential to add a pool, 39A Milk Street presents a rare opportunity to create a private island sanctuary in one of Nantucket’s most sought-after neighborhoods.

First Floor

The first floor offers a thoughtfully designed layout with two spacious en suite bedrooms. There is also a powder room. Multiple living areas—including a formal living room, a cozy sitting room, and a more casual gathering space—provide both flexibility and flow, complemented by two fireplaces that create warmth and character throughout. A formal dining area anchors the home for entertaining, while the recently renovated kitchen, complete with pantry and adjacent laundry, seamlessly blends modern function with timeless style. Sliding doors open to the back patio, inviting effortless indoor-outdoor living with space for al fresco dining and relaxation.

Second Floor

The second floor includes a primary suite, complete with a recently renovated bathroom featuring a double vanity, modern tiled shower, and a separate soaking tub for spa-like relaxation. Overlooking the main level, a balcony adds architectural interest and a sense of openness to the home. A spacious, second en suite bedroom completes this floor, offering comfort and privacy.