5 & 7 New Street Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$2,600,000
Asking Price
$2,600,000
Selling Price
Sold
Market Status
3 beds
Bedrooms
3.1 beds
Bathrooms
1,766 beds
Square Footage

Located in the heart of ‘Sconset village, next door to the beloved Chanticleer Restaurant and directly across the street from the ‘Sconset Casino and Tennis Club, “Seldom Inn” features a large, hedge-lined yard and boasts both history and character. The front portion of the house dates to the 1800s and was home to the first female minister in Massachusetts, Phebe Ann Coffin. The charming three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath cottage was originally sited along Bank Street and was moved in the early 1900s to the current oversized lot upon which it presently sits. In the 2000s, numerous updates were completed, including modernized bathrooms and a rear addition. Today, this charming property, with its ideal setting near the ‘Sconset Market, area restaurants and beaches, is ready for its next steward. It is a truly special property ready to be re-envisioned.

First Floor

The front entry opens to a living room with French doors that open to a covered side porch and a spacious side yard beyond. A kitchen with great ambient light and ample storage is to the right of the front entry. Just past the front living room is a central family room with trayed ceiling, wide plank pine floors and a gas stove. To the right is a powder room with one of two laundry areas. A doorway separates the original portion of the house to the rear addition that includes a sizeable bedroom with built-in bureaus and three large closets. A full bath with shower and tile work is nearby. At the back of the house is a spacious rear living room with a cathedral ceiling, wall-to-wall windows, a generously sized vaulted loft and access to the yard. This portion of the house has a galley kitchenette with a mini dishwasher, sink, refrigerator, and stove. There is another full hall bath with tub and a hall closet containing a second washer/dryer.

Second Floor

A large bedroom leads to a smaller captive bedroom with a lovely tin ceiling. Both bedrooms have access to a hall bath with shower and tile work.

  • Selling Date 9/15/2023
  • Listed Date 8/23/2023
  • Days on Market 23
  • % To Listing Price 100
  • Total Rooms 7
  • Total Beds 3
  • Full Baths 3
  • Half Baths 1
  • Lot Size 0.184 acres
  • Year Built 1830
  • Year Renovated 2000
  • Second Dwelling Yes
  • Zoning SOH
Listed on by Fisher Real Estate
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about Sconset

Sconset stands apart thanks to the more relaxed pace, nine-hole public golf course, wonderful restaurants, and even its own post office.

Learn more

Recommended for you

12 Netowa Lane

$2,350,000

10/9/2025

DOM: 297

3 Pinkham Circle

$4,775,000

10/9/2025

DOM: 31

48 Vesper Lane

$3,550,000

10/9/2025

DOM: 44

2 beds
2.0 beds

40A Union Street

$1,900,000

10/7/2025

DOM: 62

50 Burnell Street, Lot 21C

$1,925,000

10/7/2025

DOM: 5

2 beds
2.1 beds

13 Spring Street

$1,900,000

10/7/2025

DOM: 64

7 beds
4.0 beds

13 Cliff Road

$6,000,000

10/7/2025

DOM: 82

4 beds
4.3 beds

3 Tautemo Way

$7,875,000

10/7/2025

DOM: 59

4 beds
4.1 beds

3 Chatham Road

$3,575,000

10/7/2025

DOM: 124

8 Polliwog Pond Road

$2,900,000

10/6/2025

DOM: 11

3 beds
3.1 beds

5 Hollister Road

$3,192,500

10/6/2025

DOM: 20

6 beds
5.1 beds

15 Pleasant Street

$15,450,000

5 beds
2.1 beds

181 Polpis Road

$2,150,000

10/3/2025

DOM: 132

Lot 31 Olivers Way

$2,300,000

10/3/2025

DOM: 2

3 beds
3.2 beds

7 North Swift Rock Road

$10,800,000

10/2/2025

DOM: 119

3 beds
4.0 beds

11 First Way

$1,880,000

10/2/2025

DOM: 33

17 Lyons Lane

$2,365,000

10/2/2025

DOM: 3

4 beds
6.1 beds

12 Beach Grass Road

$2,754,000

10/2/2025

DOM: 1

9 beds
9.2 beds

10 Old Westmoor Farm Road

$9,570,000

10/1/2025

DOM: 100

6 beds
6.2 beds

30 Eel Point Road

$19,000,000

10/1/2025

DOM: 21

6 beds
6.2 beds

8 Sachem Road

$31,000,000

9/30/2025

DOM: 0

4 beds
4.1 beds

25 Broadway

$3,900,000

9/30/2025

DOM: 614

3 beds
2.0 beds

2 Saratoga Lane

$2,175,000

9/30/2025

DOM: 160

3 beds
3.0 beds

5 Tautemo Way

$4,250,000

9/29/2025

DOM: 111

2 beds
1.1 beds
933 sf beds

2 Elbow Lane

$2,075,000

9/29/2025

DOM: 86

4 beds
4.0 beds

198 Hummock Pond Road

$5,250,000

9/29/2025

DOM: 73

4 beds
1.0 beds

27 Osprey Way

$4,200,000

12 Oak Hollow Lane

$3,400,000

9/25/2025

DOM: 265

3 beds
2.0 beds

2 Towaddy Lane

$2,700,000

9/25/2025

DOM: 78

4 beds
4.1 beds

7 Lily Street

$5,025,000

9/25/2025

DOM: 42

50 Burnell Street

$2,250,000

9/24/2025

DOM: 27

4 beds
4.1 beds

2 White Elephant Way

$7,600,000

9/24/2025

DOM: 374

4 beds
3.1 beds

1 Brier Patch Road

$3,375,000

9/24/2025

DOM: 8

5 beds
4.0 beds

78 Cliff Road

$8,750,000

9/24/2025

DOM: 363

5 beds
5.1 beds

13 Derrymore Road

$4,700,000

9/24/2025

DOM: 135

5 beds
5.1 beds

33 Pleasant Street

$3,490,000

9/24/2025

DOM: 121

1 beds
1.0 beds
600 sf beds

8R Union Street

$1,800,000

8 beds
8.3 beds

17 Pilgrim Road

$6,825,000

6 beds
6.0 beds

38 Monohansett Road

$3,200,000

9/23/2025

DOM: 273

4 beds
4.0 beds

10 New Lane

$5,300,000

9/23/2025

DOM: 62

5 beds
6.2 beds

126 Main Street

$14,500,000

9/23/2025

DOM: 197

2 beds
3.1 beds

3B Yawkey Way

$1,425,000

9/19/2025

DOM: 135

4 beds
4.0 beds

137 Surfside Road

$2,600,000

9/19/2025

DOM: 112

8 Cato Lane

$875,500

9/18/2025

DOM: 37

3 beds
2.0 beds

1 Gully Road

$2,795,000

9/18/2025

DOM: 17

4 beds
6.0 beds

155 Surfside Road

$3,995,000

9/18/2025

DOM: 14

35 Vesper Lane

$2,475,000

9/18/2025

DOM: 16

4 beds
4.1 beds

83 Squam Road

$15,000,000

4 beds
2.1 beds

17 Goldfinch Drive

$2,595,000

9/17/2025

DOM: 14

West of Town
4 beds
1.1 beds

9 Dukes Road

$1,900,000

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.