- Overview
- Property Details
- Location
Discover your private island retreat at 5 Hollister Road, Nantucket, a light-filled multi-level home with sweeping views of the Atlantic Ocean and iconic Sankaty Lighthouse. Tucked away off Old Tom Nevers Road, this turnkey property welcomes you with a white shell driveway leading to the Main House and oversized garage with a spacious studio apartment above. Inside, the open and airy layout features a cathedral-ceiling living room with abundant windows, a cozy fireplace, and direct access to a wraparound deck designed to capture breathtaking ocean vistas. The bedrooms are thoughtfully located on the lower levels, creating privacy and separation from the main living spaces. The garage-level studio offers additional living space with its own large deck—perfect for guests, a home office, or rental opportunities. Just 0.3 miles from deeded beach access, this property invites endless summer days by the shore. With the potential for a pool (subject to verification), the possibilities for creating your dream Nantucket retreat are unmatched. 5 Hollister Road is a rare opportunity to own a move-in-ready home in a serene Tom Nevers location, combining ocean views, outdoor living, and flexible spaces.
First Floor
Access the lower-level bedrooms via a few stairs from the finished basement or a few stairs down from the dining area. The primary bedroom has an ensuite bathroom, a seating area, and large closets. Two additional bedrooms share a full bathroom.
Second Floor
Walk the outside stairway to access the open-space kitchen with stainless steel appliances separated by an island from the dining area and powder room. The short stairway leads to the living room.
Third Floor
Spacious, bright, light cathedral ceiling living room with fireplace, expansive windows, and doors that open to the wrap-around deck. Beautiful ocean views from most parts of the living room and deck.
- Selling Date 10/6/2025
- Listed Date 8/16/2025
- Days on Market 51
- % To Listing Price 99
- Total Rooms 8
- Total Beds 3
- Full Baths 3
- Half Baths 1
- Lot Size 0.46 acres
- Year Built 1974
- Year Renovated 2017
- Second Dwelling Yes
- Zoning LUG3
- Views Ocean
5 Hollister Road - Sales History
Location
What we like about Tom Nevers
Tom Nevers beach is a great swimming destination that features a nearby playground and a large open field. Tom Nevers is also home to beautiful south shore beaches and is a favorite spot to fish for striped bass and bluefish in the summertime.
Learn moreRecommended for you
Questions? Let us reach out to you.
Message (Optional)
Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266
A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.