Best Coffee Shops On Nantucket

12/17/2025

Nantucket coffee shops are small hubs that fuel daily life on the island. From early-morning fishermen grabbing a hot cup before sunrise to travelers seeking a cozy break, coffee in Nantucket reflects the island’s rhythm.

The blend of maritime history and modern taste creates a café scene that feels warm and unpretentious. Visitors can find everything from artisanal espresso to home-baked pastries, all served with that distinct island hospitality that makes each visit memorable.

For more tips on local favorites, itineraries, and hidden gems, explore our Nantucket Guide before heading out.

Handlebar Café

Handlebar Café is on the outskirts of downtown, and is a popular stop for both locals and visitors. The vibe is relaxed and social, as it's one of the only spots with tables to dine-in and enjoy. It has become known for its warm atmosphere and festive holiday drinks, perfect for catching up on emails or simply people-watching from a sunny corner.

Their coffee is smooth, consistent, and roasted to highlight flavor without bitterness. The Handlebar’s cozy space also doubles as a mini community center, visitors might overhear local conversations about sailing conditions or weekend events. It feels like a local tradition in cup form, making it a must-stop for anyone exploring Nantucket Island.

The Corner Table

Located in the heart of Town, The Corner Table is where simplicity meets comfort. Its compact layout hides a surprisingly full menu that includes soups, sandwiches, and baked treats alongside quality coffee. Regulars praise its consistent taste and smooth espresso.

What makes this café stand out is its friendly energy that feels like the kind of place where you can walk in once and be remembered. The Corner Table often hosts market events and cooking classes, adding an interactive touch for those looking to learn something new between sips.

Lemon Press

Bright, fresh, and full of energy, Lemon Press captures the health-conscious side of Nantucket’s coffee culture. Their menu includes vibrant breakfast bowls, avocado toast, and creative lattes that taste like summer even on a cloudy day. The modern design and attentive service make it a local favorite.

Coffee enthusiasts enjoy the quality beans and balanced flavors that complement every meal. Lemon Press draws visitors who want a little extra flair in their cup, offering matcha, turmeric, and plant-based alternatives on the menu.

It’s the ideal stop for travelers who want to enjoy a stylish café without losing the cozy island charm. Every cup here feels like a mini escape before the next beach walk or shopping stop.

Espresso To Go

The locals' pick! Espresso To Go keeps things simple and focused: strong coffee, quick service, and good vibes. It’s one of those hidden gems that reward those who step off the main tourist trail. Their coconut latte and iced mocha are local favorites, often recommended by those who know the island best.

The café’s cozy layout encourages conversation between regulars and new visitors alike. It’s the type of spot that locals depend on before work or errands. Travelers can stop in for a quick energy boost before venturing toward the scenic routes listed in the Getting Around Nantucket guide.

Espresso To Go may be small, but its quality and friendliness make it a consistent highlight for anyone chasing good coffee on the island. Tip - they offer covered outdoor seating only, a prime spot for summer and fall!

Born and Bread

Born and Bread combines traditional craftsmanship with the comfort of homemade goodness. Known for its breakfast sandwiches and fresh-baked bread, this café delivers warmth in every sense. Their coffee follows the same approach: simple, smooth, and perfectly balanced.

The café can get busy during morning rush hours, but it is worth the wait. Locals praise the freshness of the pastries, while travelers enjoy the homey atmosphere that makes the island feel smaller and friendlier.

For visitors spending a few days exploring, Born and Bread can easily become a daily ritual and a reliable start to any Nantucket morning.

45 Surfside Bakery and Café

Conveniently Mid-Island, 45 Surfside Bakery and Café rewards those who venture beyond the main streets. The space is airy and inviting, filled with natural light and the aroma of baked goods. Their espresso, made with Stumptown Coffee, gives a perfect kick to any morning routine.

Regulars love their breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwich menu. It’s an easy spot to settle into, with open seating and friendly service. The café blends modern coffee trends with the easygoing island lifestyle. It feels approachable and genuine, creating the kind of atmosphere that turns a quick stop into an extended stay.

Roastd General Store

Roastd General Store brings a refreshing twist to Nantucket’s coffee scene. Part café, part general store, it offers great brews alongside local goods and a small CBD selection. Visitors often describe it as a peaceful retreat from the busier downtown pace.

The coffee is rich and aromatic, served with care and a bit of island charm. Roastd’s outdoor seating makes it an excellent option for sunny mornings or lazy afternoons. Located just outside Town, it offers a slightly different view of local life, more relaxed, more personal, and just as memorable.

Wicked Island Bakery

Wicked Island Bakery is a local gem with a loyal following that does coffee right. Known for its morning buns and baked goods, it also offers satisfying, straightforward coffee. This is not a place for pretense, just good flavors and genuine service.

Visitors can stop in for breakfast, pick up treats for the beach, or take a moment to relax. The staff keeps the atmosphere cheerful, and the prices remain reasonable, which is always a plus on the island. Wicked Island Bakery shows that great coffee does not need fancy décor, only care and consistency.

Experience Nantucket’s Café Culture with Great Point Properties

Here at Great Point Properties, we understand that finding the right coffee spot is part of enjoying island life. We help visitors and homeowners connect with Nantucket’s authentic experiences, from scenic routes to local hangouts. Our deep roots on the island mean we know where to find the best sips and the quietest corners.

Explore our Nantucket Guide and local resources to make your stay richer, warmer, and more connected, just like a good cup of coffee.