Nantucket MLS

The Top Coffee Shops on Nantucket, Ranked

09/02/2025

Nantucket runs on salty air, cobblestones, and caffeine. Whether you’re grabbing an oat milk latte before biking out to Sconset, sneaking in a remote work session by the harbor, or treating yourself to something sweet after the beach, the island’s coffee scene offers much more than just a quick caffeine boost. Each café has its character, quirks, and a loyal following that swears by it. Here’s our list of Nantucket’s coffee shops with complete price ranges, signature drinks, reviewer favorites, and Wi-Fi or workspace vibes.

1. Handlebar Café ($$$)

Signature drink: Cold Brew with house-made vanilla syrup

What people say: “Best latte art on the island,” “Garden patio feels like an oasis,” “Baristas who care.”

Vibe: Vintage bike theme, backyard seating, lots of personality.

Handlebar is a true Nantucket treasure. The coffee is always top-notch, and their cold brew has a devoted following, while their lattes are both visually stunning and flavorful. The front patio is one of the best-kept secrets for relaxing with a book, and inside, you’ll often see local art displayed on the walls.

Wi-Fi/workspace notes: Reliable Wi-Fi, plenty of tables, and the kind of background buzz that makes it easy to focus. Best for writers, remote workers, or anyone seeking a “third place” atmosphere.

2. Island Coffee ($$)

Signature drink: Classic house dark blend (black coffee, done right)

What people say: “Best straight-up coffee on Nantucket,” “No frills, just great beans.”

Vibe: Bright, casual, efficient.

Island Coffee is all about simplicity done well. No turmeric foams, no experimental add-ons. Just carefully roasted beans and a reliably strong cup. It’s a local go-to before the ferry or a morning bike ride, with a refreshing back-to-basics charm that sets it apart from trendier spots.

Wi-Fi/workspace notes: Minimal seating and quick turnover. Best for a quick boost on the go rather than a laptop session.

3. Corner Table Café ($$)

Signature drink: Americano with a breakfast sandwich on the side

What people say: “The breakfast sandwiches are the best on the island,” “Cozy and community-driven,” “Perfect post-bike ride stop.”

Vibe: Warm, bookish, board games in the corner.

Corner Table is that rare café that feels like an extension of your living room. You’ll see families grabbing a bite after morning rides, friends chatting over lattes, and someone tucked away in the corner writing with headphones on. Their beans are roasted in-house, and their food is worth planning around.

Wi-Fi/workspace notes: Excellent spot for working or hanging out. Wi-Fi is strong, tables are spread out enough for laptops, and the energy is cozy without being too loud.

4. Lemon Press ($$)

Signature drink: The “Grey Lady” (lavender latte) or “Gold Dust” (turmeric latte)

What people say: “Best healthy options on Nantucket,” “Bright, airy, beautiful,” “Where wellness meets caffeine.”

Vibe: Trendy, health-forward, Instagram-worthy.

If Handlebar is the quirky cousin, Lemon Press is the stylish wellness guru. It’s the place to go if you want your coffee with oat milk, a shot of turmeric, and maybe a vegan pastry on the side. The space is clean, modern, and lively. It’s the kind of spot where you feel like you should be wearing linen and sunglasses indoors.

Wi-Fi/workspace notes: Wi-Fi is solid, but tables fill up quickly. Best for a quick session or for remote workers who thrive in a lively, bustling space.

5. Provisions ($$)

Signature drink: Cappuccino + Turkey Terrific sandwich (yes, that’s the combo)

What people say: “Best harbor view coffee,” “Balanced cappuccinos,” “My ferry ritual.”

Vibe: Scenic, classic, and very Nantucket.

Provisions might be better known for its sandwiches (if you know, you know: Turkey Terrific), but their coffee holds its own. Having a cappuccino by the harbor truly captures the island vibe. It's the perfect spot before or after catching the ferry.

Wi-Fi/workspace notes: Wi-Fi is spotty, and this is not a work spot. Think harbor views, not laptops.

6. Roastd General Store ($$$)

Signature drink: Espresso tonic with house-made nut milk

What people say: “Hidden gem,” “Creative coffee with wellness twist,” “Love the CBD latte options.”

Vibe: Quirky, modern, slightly experimental.

Roastd is where coffee truly shines. Think homemade nut milks, organic beans, espresso tonics, and even CBD-infused lattes. It has that Brooklyn-meets-Nantucket vibe, a little off the beaten path but worth it if you enjoy exploring new flavors.

Wi-Fi/workspace notes: Mid-island, less crowded, and a strong pick if you’re serious about camping out with your laptop. Plenty of locals do the same.

Multiple Locations: Roastd has numerous locations around the island, including an airport and two mid-island stores.

7. Espresso To Go ($$)

Signature drink: Coconut latte or iced mocha

What people say: “Quickest service,” “Perfect before a beach day,” “Surprisingly great coconut latte.”

Vibe: Efficient, unpretentious, grab-and-go.

Espresso To Go isn’t fancy, but that’s part of its appeal. It's the perfect place for anyone heading to Surfside with sandy feet and sunscreen still drying. Their coconut latte has a loyal fan base, and their iced drinks are great for cooling off after a long day in the sun.

Wi-Fi/workspace notes: It's not just a workspace; consider it as a place to 'fuel up and head out.”

Final Sip

Nantucket’s coffee culture is as diverse as its beaches: some spots invite you to linger all morning, others are quick pit stops, and a few experiment with drinks you didn’t know you needed.

For working: Handlebar Café, Corner Table, Roastd General Store
For quick grab-and-go: Island Coffee Roasters, Espresso To Go
For healthy/creative vibes: Lemon Press, Roastd General Store
For scenery: Provisions