1 South Mill Street Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$2,275,000
Asking Price
Off-market
Market Status
1 beds
Bedrooms
1 beds
Bathrooms
645 beds
Square Footage

1 South Mill Street Nantucket is a rare single-family home created from a thoughtfully restored antique garage, ideally located just off Pleasant Street on the quiet and charming South Mill Street. This distinctive Nantucket property seamlessly blends historic character with refined modern design, offering a truly unique living experience in Town. The open-concept floor plan at 1 South Mill Street Nantucket is anchored by a chef’s kitchen featuring high-end appliances, custom cabinetry, and elegant marble tile finishes. Dramatic cathedral ceilings with exposed beams elevate the main living area, filling the space with light and architectural interest. A cozy fireplace adds warmth and year-round comfort. Additional highlights include a private outdoor shower, convenient off-street parking, and a tranquil setting that feels tucked away while remaining moments from Nantucket’s shops, dining, and harbor. With its exceptional location, craftsmanship, and charm, 1 South Mill Street Nantucket is a truly special opportunity in one of Nantucket’s most desirable neighborhoods.

First Floor

A welcoming foyer offers smart, utilitarian closet storage before opening into a bright, open concept living, dining and kitchen space. The kitchen is outfitted with top of the line appliances and a striking marble backsplash, seamlessly blending style and function. An antique brick wall and reconstructed mahogany front door add warmth and character. The living area features a fireplace flanked by custom built-ins, along with additional refrigeration for effortless entertaining. A stylish bathroom provides direct access to an outdoor shower, creating a spa like experience. Washer and dryer. The large bedroom offers generous closet space and a comfortable, private retreat.

  • Selling Date
  • Listed Date 1/25/2026
  • Days on Market NaN
  • % To Listing Price 0
  • Total Rooms 2
  • Total Beds 1
  • Full Baths 1
  • Lot Size 0.0257 acres
  • Year Built 1920
  • Year Renovated 2026
  • Zoning ROH
Listed on by J Pepper Frazier Co.
1 South Mill Street - Sales History
  • Selling date: 6/24/2024
    Selling price: $900,000
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about South Of Town

Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.

Learn more

Recommended for you

3 beds
2.1 beds

21 Exeter Street

$2,900,000

8/11/2026

DOM: 12

3 beds
2.0 beds

7 Sandpiper Way

$2,350,000

8/10/2026

DOM: 59

4 beds
4.1 beds

10 Pilgrim Road

$3,900,000

8/10/2026

DOM: 125

7 Fawn Lane

$1,100,000

8/10/2026

DOM: 8

9 Fawn Lane

$1,100,000

8/10/2026

DOM: 8

2 Paupamo Way

$2,800,000

8/7/2026

DOM: 3

West of Town
2 beds
1.0 beds
880 sf beds

49A West Chester Street

$1,600,000

8/7/2026

DOM: 77

 
0.1 beds
649 sf beds

26 Easy Street

$2,000,000

8/5/2026

DOM: 74

3 beds
2.1 beds

9 Carew Lane

$4,200,000

8/4/2026

DOM: 2

7 beds
8.2 beds

247 Polpis Road

$7,675,000

8/4/2026

DOM: 187

3 beds
2.1 beds

7 White Street

$4,500,000

8/4/2026

DOM: 0

5 beds
5.1 beds

6 Mariner Way

$5,250,000

7/31/2026

DOM: 235

5 beds
3.0 beds

23 Liberty Street

$4,200,000

7/31/2026

DOM: 49

27 Nonantum Avenue

$12,900,000

West of Town
3 beds
2.0 beds

42 Vestal Street

$2,725,000

7/30/2026

DOM: 48

6 beds
5.0 beds

2 Eli Place

$3,000,000

4 beds
2.1 beds

14 Flintlock Road

$2,625,000

7/24/2026

DOM: 344

4 beds
4.0 beds

27 North Liberty Street

$4,475,000

7/24/2026

DOM: 259

5 beds
5.2 beds

4 Red Mill Lane

$5,862,000

7/24/2026

DOM: 173

4 beds
3.0 beds

22 Sheep Pond Road

$2,075,000

7/22/2026

DOM: 951

3 beds
2.1 beds

321 Madaket Road

$2,975,000

7/20/2026

DOM: 225

4 beds
4.0 beds

2 Goldenrod Court

$2,535,000

7/17/2026

DOM: 258

6 beds
3.0 beds

47 Morey Lane

$3,500,000

7/17/2026

DOM: 202

2 beds
2.0 beds

1 H Street

$2,050,000

7/17/2026

DOM: 37

6 beds
4.2 beds

5 Surrey Avenue

$6,695,000

7/15/2026

DOM: 15

5 beds
6.1 beds

4 Crown Court

$5,150,000

7/14/2026

DOM: 51

5 Nonantum Avenue

$3,490,000

7/13/2026

DOM: 41

11 & 13 Sun Island Road

$3,080,800

West of Town
3 beds
2.0 beds

15 Meadow Lane

$3,305,000

7/9/2026

DOM: 3

1 beds
1.0 beds
508 sf beds

1 Webster Road

$854,171

7/8/2026

DOM: 1

3 beds
2.0 beds

3 Appleton Road

$1,600,000

6 Bittersweet Lane

$1,525,000

7/7/2026

DOM: 276

West of Town
2 beds
2.0 beds

30 Dukes Road

$3,325,000

7/7/2026

DOM: 2

5 beds
4.1 beds

33 Pine Street

$3,500,000

7/2/2026

DOM: 247

36 Easton Street

$25,000,000

7/2/2026

DOM: 739

3 beds
2.0 beds

1 Saratoga Lane

$3,250,000

7/2/2026

DOM: 5

3 beds
2.0 beds

24 Milk Street

$2,985,000

7/1/2026

DOM: 5

9 beds
7.3 beds

21 Quidnet Road

$8,500,000

6/30/2026

DOM: 311

 
1.0 beds
786 sf beds

2E Sanford Road

$565,000

5 beds
5.1 beds

8 Priscilla Lane

$5,450,000

6/29/2026

DOM: 84

3 beds
2.0 beds

5 Rudder Lane

$2,652,000

6/26/2026

DOM: 3

2 Wingspread Lane

$6,000,000

7 beds
3.0 beds

12 Atlantic Avenue

$1,974,000

3 beds
2.0 beds

10 Coffin Street

$2,445,000

6/23/2026

DOM: 8

4 beds
2.0 beds

254 Madaket Road

$2,300,000

3 beds
2.1 beds

17 Pond View Drive

$4,400,000

6/18/2026

DOM: 261

4 beds
3.1 beds

19 Orange Street

$4,112,500

6/18/2026

DOM: 499

3 beds
3.0 beds

12 1/2 Ipswich Street

$2,690,938

6/16/2026

DOM: 339

2 beds
2.0 beds
957 sf beds

16H Milestone Road

$1,625,000

6/15/2026

DOM: 196

1 beds
1.0 beds
425 sf beds

24 Washington Avenue

$1,650,000

6/15/2026

DOM: 13

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.