Menu

508-228-2266 Subscribe for New Listing Updates

Subscribe for New Listing Updates

2 Cathcart Road Nantucket, MA 02554

Overview
Property Details
Location

$3,495,000

Asking Price

$3,200,000

Selling Price

Sold

Market Status

0

beds

Bedrooms

null

beds

Bathrooms

Create your Nantucket compound on this incredibly private, oversized Monomoy lot with Harbor views. Just under 4,000 SF of ground cover available which is plenty of room for a main house, cottage, pool, the possibilities here are, quite literally, endless. Sewer and water tie-in available at Cathcart and Brewster Roads.

Selling Date 1/19/2022
Listed Date 6/30/2021
Days on Market 203
% To Listing Price 92

Lot Size 1.3019 acres

Zoning LUG1
Views Hbr, Pasture

Listed on June 30, 2021 by Lee Real Estate

2 Cathcart Road - Sales History

Selling date: 2/22/2002

Selling price: $1,350,000

View Listing

Location

What we like about Monomoy

Close to Town and the serene beaches of Polpis, Monomoy has one of the best dog-friendly walking beaches. Featuring a large harbor and great shellfishing, catch beautiful views of Town and the Harbor.

Recommended for you

47 Morey Lane - Sconset, Nantucket MA

6

3.0

47 Morey Lane

$3,500,000

7/17/2026

DOM: 202

4 Crown Court - Town, Nantucket MA

5

6.1

4 Crown Court

$5,150,000

7/14/2026

DOM: 51

5 Nonantum Avenue - Surfside, Nantucket MA

5 Nonantum Avenue

$3,490,000

7/13/2026

DOM: 41

15 Meadow Lane - West of Town, Nantucket MA

West of Town

3

2.0

15 Meadow Lane

$3,305,000

7/9/2026

DOM: 3

1 Webster Road - Surfside, Nantucket MA

1

1.0

508 sf

1 Webster Road

$854,171

7/8/2026

DOM: 1

6 Bittersweet Lane - South of Town, Nantucket MA

6 Bittersweet Lane

$1,525,000

7/7/2026

DOM: 276

30 Dukes Road - West of Town, Nantucket MA

West of Town

2

2.0

30 Dukes Road

$3,325,000

7/7/2026

DOM: 2

33 Pine Street - Town, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

33 Pine Street

$3,500,000

7/2/2026

DOM: 247

36 Easton Street - Brant Point, Nantucket MA

9

9.1

36 Easton Street

$25,000,000

7/2/2026

DOM: 739

24 Milk Street - Town, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

24 Milk Street

$2,985,000

7/1/2026

DOM: 5

1 Saratoga Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

1 Saratoga Lane

$3,250,000

7/1/2026

DOM: 5

21 Quidnet Road - Quidnet, Nantucket MA

9

7.3

21 Quidnet Road

$8,500,000

6/30/2026

DOM: 311

2E Sanford Road - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

1.0

786 sf

2E Sanford Road

$565,000

8 Priscilla Lane - Cliff, Nantucket MA

5

5.1

8 Priscilla Lane

$5,450,000

6/29/2026

DOM: 84

5 Rudder Lane - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

5 Rudder Lane

$2,652,000

6/26/2026

DOM: 3

2 Wingspread Lane - Shawkemo, Nantucket MA

2 Wingspread Lane

$6,000,000

12 Atlantic Avenue - Town, Nantucket MA

7

3.0

12 Atlantic Avenue

$1,974,000

10 Coffin Street - Town, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

10 Coffin Street

$2,445,000

6/23/2026

DOM: 8

254 Madaket Road - Madaket, Nantucket MA

4

2.0

254 Madaket Road

$2,300,000

17 Pond View Drive - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

17 Pond View Drive

$4,400,000

6/18/2026

DOM: 261

19 Orange Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

3.1

19 Orange Street

$4,112,500

6/18/2026

DOM: 499

12 1/2 Ipswich Street - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

3

3.0

12 1/2 Ipswich Street

$2,690,938

6/16/2026

DOM: 339

16H Milestone Road - Monomoy, Nantucket MA

2

2.0

957 sf

16H Milestone Road

$1,625,000

6/15/2026

DOM: 196

24 Washington Avenue - Madaket, Nantucket MA

1

1.0

425 sf

24 Washington Avenue

$1,650,000

6/15/2026

DOM: 13

52 Pleasant Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

2.1

52 Pleasant Street

$2,150,000

6/15/2026

DOM: 281

20 Rudder Lane - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

4

2.1

20 Rudder Lane

$2,650,000

6/15/2026

DOM: 6

15 Kendrick Street - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

3

3.0

15 Kendrick Street

$2,250,000

6/12/2026

DOM: 4

9 Pleasant Street - Town, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

9 Pleasant Street

$9,650,000

6/12/2026

DOM: 373

45A Beach Grass Road - Sandpiper, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

45A Beach Grass Road

$876,000

163 Orange Street - South of Town, Nantucket MA

4

5.1

163 Orange Street

$3,202,009

6/11/2026

DOM: 12

44 Sankaty Road - Sconset, Nantucket MA

4

3.1

44 Sankaty Road

$4,212,500

6/9/2026

DOM: 258

96A Pleasant Street - Town, Nantucket MA

1

1.0

485 sf

96A Pleasant Street

$1,250,000

34 Pine Street - Town, Nantucket MA

3

4.0

34 Pine Street

$2,325,000

6/8/2026

DOM: 288

10 Rudder Lane - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

10 Rudder Lane

$4,150,000

6/3/2026

DOM: 22

4 Eagle Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

4

3.0

4 Eagle Lane

$2,945,000

6/1/2026

DOM: 0

10 Evergreen Way - Surfside, Nantucket MA

10 Evergreen Way

$450,000

6 Eagle Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

6 Eagle Lane

$2,300,000

5/30/2026

DOM: 184

42 North Liberty Street - Town, Nantucket MA

2

2.0

42 North Liberty Street

$2,650,000

5/29/2026

DOM: 26

7 Miacomet Avenue - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

7 Miacomet Avenue

$1,100,000

5/29/2026

DOM: 72

13 Eat Fire Spring Road - Wauwinet, Nantucket MA

4

2.1

13 Eat Fire Spring Road

$3,800,594

5/29/2026

DOM: 56

15 Old North Wharf - Town, Nantucket MA

2

1.1

880 sf

15 Old North Wharf

$3,800,000

5/22/2026

DOM: 0

4 Berkley Street - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

4 Berkley Street

$1,925,000

5/21/2026

DOM: 136

4 Shawkemo Hills Lane - Shawkemo, Nantucket MA

8

6.2

4 Shawkemo Hills Lane

$10,000,000

5/20/2026

DOM: 222

22 Washington Avenue - Madaket, Nantucket MA

22 Washington Avenue

$250,000

5/20/2026

DOM: 0

74 Madaket Road - West of Town, Nantucket MA

West of Town

74 Madaket Road

$2,875,000

5/20/2026

DOM: 160

87 Goldfinch Drive - Naushop, Nantucket MA

4

4.0

87 Goldfinch Drive

$2,325,000

5/19/2026

DOM: 3

85R Orange Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

3.1

85R Orange Street

$3,000,000

5/19/2026

DOM: 247

11 Hydrangea Lane - Sconset, Nantucket MA

3

4.1

11 Hydrangea Lane

$4,025,000

5/15/2026

DOM: 18

14 West Creek Road - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

14 West Creek Road

$990,000

31 Flintlock Road - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

31 Flintlock Road

$2,595,000

5/11/2026

DOM: 90

View All Listings

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

Message (Optional)
Message

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.