23 Broad Street is a commercial building in the old historic district of Nantucket. The lower level of the building was formerly operated as the "Brotherhood of Thieves" restaurant and bar. The cozy iconic gathering place was originally established in 1972 and was reminiscent of an 1840's whaling bar. The Brotherhood was recognized as a well established gathering place for locals and tourists for many years. Nine residential rooms on the third and fourth floor were used as employee housing. There are two parking places and a loading zone.
Floor Plans
The second level or the first floor is the main entrance/lobby, consists of a large bar with street views of Broad Street, two spacious dining rooms, gas fireplace, service station, two restrooms, a commercial kitchen, managers office and a two stop elevator.
- Total Rooms 15
- Total Beds 9
- Full Baths 2
- Half Baths 7
- Lot Size 0.23 acres
- Year Built 1850
- Year Renovated 2004
- Zoning CDT
Location
What we like about Town
Often referred to as the heartbeat of the island, Town truly has it all! From historic homes to cobblestone streets and world-class dining and shopping, one can spend days on end wandering through.
Learn more
Questions? Let us reach out to you.
Message (Optional)
Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266
A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm