3 & 5 Joy Street Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$2,600,000
Asking Price
$2,350,000
Selling Price
Sold
Market Status
3 beds
Bedrooms
2.1 beds
Bathrooms
2,591 beds
Square Footage

Two separate, largely oversized and conforming properties, 3 and 5 Joy Street, for sale together on a charming Town road.  3 Joy Street is an 11,000+ sf lot improved by the Captain Joy House, which was originally built in 1799 and is a piece of Nantucket's history. The house was thoughtfully restored and added onto in 2001 resulting in over 2,500 sf of living space.  There is over 1,300 sf of ground cover available to expand the house or build a cottage and/or garage.  5 Joy Street is an 11,000+ sf lot with over 3,300 sf of ground cover available and Town Water and Sewer available.  Both properties are allowed a house, cottage and pool.  They are meticulously landscaped and present versatility to the discriminating Buyer-keep both and build a compound, build your dream house and rent the existing house, sell one and keep the other.  Rare opportunity to own two large parcels in Town. ***The vacant lot could potentially be for sale separately.

First Floor

Entering side door into a well-lit hallway leading to a large eat-in kitchen, opening onto a family room/dining room with fireplace. Study. Front living room, facing Joy Street. Hallway leads to stairs to second floor. At the rear of the house over-looking stunning gardens and a pergola, is the master suite with full bathroom, walk-in closet, and fireplace. Separate door to back yard. Power room, laundry room, and basement access.

Second Floor

Two bedrooms, and a hall full bathroom with tub and shower.

  • Selling Date 5/23/2014
  • Listed Date 3/15/2013
  • Days on Market 434
  • % To Listing Price 90
  • Total Rooms 8
  • Total Beds 3
  • Full Baths 2
  • Half Baths 1
  • Lot Size 0.53 acres
  • Year Built 1799
  • Year Renovated 2001
  • Second Dwelling Yes
  • Zoning R1
Listed on by J Pepper Frazier Co.
3 & 5 Joy Street - Sales History
  • Selling date: 11/14/2025
    Selling price: $3,150,000
  • Selling date: 10/7/2022
    Selling price: $2,325,000
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about South Of Town

Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.

Learn more
Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.