- Overview
- Property Details
- Location
An amazing canvas for creative visionaries to bring something new to Downtown. With two buildings on an oversized corner lot, there is significant infrastructure in place to accelerate the next project. A unique opportunity to re-develop a prime piece of Nantucket commercial real estate. Approximately 7186 sqft of finished interior space in the existing theater building and 1,907 sqft of finished interior space in the antique house. There are a multitude of complementing mixed use options to consider here. Some allowable uses in CDT: residential, retail, restaurant/bar/tavern, hotel, personal services, spa, offices, gallery, bakery & market. Condominium eligible.
First Floor
The theatre building was completed in 2016 with an intimate stage inside a voluminous three story building. The design was conceived as a Maritime Wharehouse with oversized doors that open into the courtyard from inside the theatre. The lobby is a spacious and light filled reception area with windows on Whalers Lane and doors to the courtyard. The side wing has stairs up to the office and down to the full basement. Within the theatre there are nine elevating rows of seating to view the stage. There is a side exit/entry door at the foot of the stage that opens to the side alley with brick walkway. An upper tier door opens to the staircase landing in the cathedral vaulted foyer space. Accessible half bath and elevator.
Second Floor
Accessed by the open staircase in the vaulted foyer, the mezzanine level houses the tech booth for sound and lighting control. There are also two tiers of seating here. In the other wing of the building there is an office accessed by separate stairs.
- Selling Date 4/11/2025
- Listed Date 6/10/2024
- Days on Market 305
- % To Listing Price 73
- Total Rooms 19
- Total Beds 5
- Full Baths 4
- Half Baths 7
- Lot Size 0.1852 acres
- Year Built 1850
- Second Dwelling Yes
- Zoning CDT
5 North Water Street - Sales History
Location
What we like about South Of Town
Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.
Learn moreRecommended for you
43 Vestal Street
$7,300,000
10/5/2026
DOM: 58
67 Vestal Street
$11,250,000
10/2/2026
DOM: 44
9 Priscilla Lane
$3,800,000
9/30/2026
DOM: 61
37 Vestal Street
$5,925,000
9/23/2026
DOM: 12
Questions? Let us reach out to you.
Message (Optional)
Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266
A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.