- Overview
- Property Details
- Location
Discover the timeless charm of 55 Orange Street, Nantucket—an iconic five-bedroom historic home originally built in 1824 by Captain John C. Gardner. Located in the heart of Nantucket’s Old Historic District, this classic four-bay residence blends preserved 19th-century craftsmanship with modern luxury across four beautifully finished levels. Meticulously renovated in 2007, the home retains many original antique features—from wide-plank floors to hand-hewn beams—while incorporating upscale updates designed for today's lifestyle. Set on a sunny corner lot at Orange and Lyon Street, this property offers rare two-car off-street parking, lush gardens, and elegant outdoor living spaces.
First Floor
A gracious and inviting entry hall announces the richness of character and refined details throughout the house. The front parlor is a welcoming room with a central fireplace and original wood mantlepiece. The second parlor flows to the rear of the house and the fabulous kitchen. Between the entry hall and the kitchen is an elegant dining room with another exquisite fireplace. A custom built-in bar is fashioned between the parlors and the kitchen island beautifully balances a work space with entertaining and casual dining. Recently renovated and expanded, the planning and outfitting of the kitchen are superb. A powder room and side entrance complete the first floor. The consistency of original doors, fitting hardware and woodwork are an impressive part of the aesthetic.
Second Floor
The front stairs lead to a wonderful landing ideal for a writing desk and reading chair. The perfect nook. The front guest suite has peeks of harbor views and an ensuite bath. The central room with an adjacent full marble bath offers flexibility for sleeping, office or an additional living area. At the rear of the house the primary suite enjoys a great southeast corner of windows, a wall of custom closets and built-in drawers, and a dedicated washer and dryer. The primary bath has a cathedral ceiling, a classic free standing soaking tub, glass enclosed shower and two vanities. The rear stairs wind down to the kitchen and up to the third floor bedrooms.
Third Floor
In this space the two additional bedrooms are symmetrical off the open landing. There is a shared shower bath and a Clearlight Sanctuary full-spectrum infrared sauna in the spacious landing area. One of the bedrooms has a stair access to the widow’s walk. Stunning views across Town and deep into the harbor. This level functions beautifully as a guest retreat, office space, or flexible overflow sleeping quarters.
- Selling Date 10/30/2025
- Listed Date 7/18/2025
- Days on Market 104
- % To Listing Price 97
- Total Rooms 12
- Total Beds 5
- Full Baths 5
- Half Baths 1
- Lot Size 0.1 acres
- Year Built 1824
- Year Renovated 2007
- Zoning ROH
- Views D/Hbr
55 Orange Street - Sales History
Location
What we like about South Of Town
Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.
Learn more
Questions? Let us reach out to you.
Message (Optional)
Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266
A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.