Menu

Nantucket MLS

69 Orange Street Nantucket, MA 02554

Overview
Property Details
Location

$5,195,000

Asking Price

4

beds

Bedrooms

4.1

beds

Bathrooms

3,024

beds

Square Footage

This beautifully restored and well-maintained federal-style home from the 1830s, located on historic Orange Street, offers a perfect blend of antique charm and modern comforts. It's an ideal property for someone who values both historical character and contemporary upgrades. The home features three finished levels of living space with four bedrooms and four-and-a-half baths. Additionally, it boasts meticulously cared-for gardens, stone walls and a patio area for seating, offering both functional living space and outdoor enjoyment. The home is complete with historic details such as 6 working fireplaces, uncommonly high ceilings, classic mortgage button in newel post and NHC designated exterior plaque.

First Floor

Step into the welcoming foyer with staircase leading to second floor. Formal parlor with fireplace connected to formal dining room with fireplace. There is a comfortable, library with fireplace leading to large, updated kitchen with casual dining area. There is also a convenient powder room with a back staircase leading to the second floor. The terrace door opens to a porch and beautiful gardens.

Second Floor

Large Front bedroom with fireplace and en-suite full bath. Primary bedroom with fireplace and ensuite full bath, with it's fireplace. The back bedroom includes built-in library shelving, a full bath and access to a back staircase leading to the first floor.

Third Floor

The finished third floor features a built-in twin bed with plenty of space for additional beds. It includes a full bathroom. The hall has a convenient pull-down staircase leading to a large roof walk.

Selling Date 10/3/2025
Listed Date 5/19/2025
Days on Market 137
% To Listing Price 0

Total Rooms 8
Total Beds 4
Full Baths 4
Half Baths 1

Lot Size 0.12 acres
Year Built 1830
Year Renovated 2001

Zoning ROH
Views D/Hbr, Res

Listed on 5/19/2025 by Maury People Sotheby's International Realty

Location

What we like about South Of Town

Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.

Recommended for you

256 Polpis Road - Polpis, Nantucket MA

12

12.3

256 Polpis Road

$33,000,000

110 Baxter Road - Sconset, Nantucket MA

7

6.1

110 Baxter Road

$7,200,000

4 McKinley Avenue - Sconset, Nantucket MA

2

1.0

4 McKinley Avenue

$3,775,000

19 Vesper Lane - South of Town, Nantucket MA

4

3.1

19 Vesper Lane

$2,650,000

9 Pleasant Street - Town, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

9 Pleasant Street

$10,995,000

15 Hallowell Lane - Cliff, Nantucket MA

4

4.1

15 Hallowell Lane

$22,000,000

10 Milk Street - Town, Nantucket MA

6

5.1

10 Milk Street

$5,495,000

2 Lily Street - Sconset, Nantucket MA

6

3.0

2 Lily Street

$4,200,000

16A Boynton Lane - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

2

1.0

955 sf

16A Boynton Lane

$925,000

20 Evergreen Way - Surfside, Nantucket MA

4

4.0

20 Evergreen Way

$3,195,000

34 Pine Street - Town, Nantucket MA

3

4.0

34 Pine Street

$2,695,000

9 Millbrook Road (Portion) - Hummock Pond, Nantucket MA

9 Millbrook Road (Portion)

$3,300,000

25C Pine Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

4.0

25C Pine Street

$5,195,000

16 Atlantic Avenue - Town, Nantucket MA

4

2.2

16 Atlantic Avenue

$2,450,000

35 West Chester Street - Town, Nantucket MA

3

1.1

35 West Chester Street

$4,400,000

20 East Lincoln Avenue & 13 Cornish Court - Brant Point, Nantucket MA

4

1.1

20 East Lincoln Avenue & 13 Cornish Court

$3,200,000

17 Cannonbury Lane - Sconset, Nantucket MA

7

7.3

17 Cannonbury Lane

$6,995,000

4 Gay Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

5.1

4 Gay Street

$8,950,000

51 Weweeder Avenue - Surfside, Nantucket MA

7

8.3

51 Weweeder Avenue

$15,650,000

12 Academy Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

4

4.1

12 Academy Lane

$6,295,000

26 Tennessee Avenue - Madaket, Nantucket MA

4

2.1

26 Tennessee Avenue

$5,495,000

20 Liberty Street - Town, Nantucket MA

5

4.1

20 Liberty Street

$8,250,000

6 Mariner Way - Town, Nantucket MA

5

5.1

6 Mariner Way

$5,895,000

2 Mariner Way - Town, Nantucket MA

4

4.1

2 Mariner Way

$5,795,000

59 South Shore Road - Surfside, Nantucket MA

8

8.1

59 South Shore Road

$39,900,000

39A Milk Street - West of Town, Nantucket MA

West of Town

5

5.1

39A Milk Street

$5,500,000

25 Nobadeer Avenue Lot 1 - Surfside, Nantucket MA

25 Nobadeer Avenue Lot 1

$4,500,000

25 Nobadeer Avenue Lot 2 - Surfside, Nantucket MA

25 Nobadeer Avenue Lot 2

$3,500,000

36 Lovers Lane - Surfside, Nantucket MA

3

3.2

36 Lovers Lane

$5,950,000

13 Eat Fire Spring Road - Wauwinet, Nantucket MA

13 Eat Fire Spring Road

$4,599,000

56R Madequecham Valley Road - Madequecham, Nantucket MA

4

4.1

56R Madequecham Valley Road

$9,995,000

6 Honeysuckle Drive - Sandpiper, Nantucket MA

6 Honeysuckle Drive

$1,350,000

15 Gingy Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

10

9.4

15 Gingy Lane

$8,650,000

17 Pond View Drive - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

17 Pond View Drive

$4,499,000

3 Cottage Avenue - Sconset, Nantucket MA

1

1.0

423 sf

3 Cottage Avenue

$1,595,000

2 Goldenrod Court - Sandpiper, Nantucket MA

4

4.0

2 Goldenrod Court

$2,499,900

4 Red Mill Lane - South of Town, Nantucket MA

5

5.2

4 Red Mill Lane

$7,295,000

20 Nancy Ann Lane - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

20 Nancy Ann Lane

$1,599,000

1 Pinkham Circle - Hummock Pond, Nantucket MA

7

4.0

1 Pinkham Circle

$2,695,000

27 Cato Lane - South of Town, Nantucket MA

9

8.3

27 Cato Lane

$8,495,000

6 Eagle Lane - Town, Nantucket MA

3

2.0

6 Eagle Lane

$2,495,000

85R Orange Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

3.1

85R Orange Street

$3,395,000

4 Morgan Square - Surfside, Nantucket MA

6

7.1

4 Morgan Square

$6,250,000

25B Park Circle - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

3

2.1

25B Park Circle

$999,500

3 & 3A Reeds Way - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

9

6.0

3 & 3A Reeds Way

$8,995,000

1 Reeds Way - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

6

4.1

1 Reeds Way

$9,995,000

1,3,&3A Reeds Way - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

15

10.1

1,3,&3A Reeds Way

$18,990,000

4 Millbrook Road - Hummock Pond, Nantucket MA

8

6.2

4 Millbrook Road

$8,995,000

24 Meadow View Drive - Hummock Pond, Nantucket MA

5

5.0

24 Meadow View Drive

$5,775,000

37 Union Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

4.1

37 Union Street

$4,295,000

50 Lovers Lane - Surfside, Nantucket MA

4

4.0

50 Lovers Lane

$4,895,000

7 Moors End Lane - Middle Moors, Nantucket MA

7

8.1

7 Moors End Lane

$10,995,000

4 Cathcart Road - Monomoy, Nantucket MA

4 Cathcart Road

$12,450,000

25 Pond View Drive - Miacomet, Nantucket MA

6

5.0

25 Pond View Drive

$5,950,000

85 Orange Street - Town, Nantucket MA

9

7.1

85 Orange Street

$10,995,000

11 Woodland Drive - Surfside, Nantucket MA

11 Woodland Drive

$1,650,000

105 Low Beach Road - Sconset, Nantucket MA

5

5.0

105 Low Beach Road

$13,995,000

3 Nobadeer Avenue - Surfside, Nantucket MA

4

5.1

3 Nobadeer Avenue

$9,650,000

18 Mill Street - Town, Nantucket MA

6

5.1

18 Mill Street

$7,495,000

174 Cliff Road - Cliff, Nantucket MA

7

7.2

174 Cliff Road

$16,500,000

52 Pleasant Street - Town, Nantucket MA

4

2.1

52 Pleasant Street

$2,395,000

42 Chuck Hollow Road - Tom Nevers, Nantucket MA

8

4.2

42 Chuck Hollow Road

$8,495,000

65B Surfside Road - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

65B Surfside Road

$849,000

3D Windy Way - Mid Island, Nantucket MA

2

1.0

745 sf

3D Windy Way

$860,000

32 Union Street - Town, Nantucket MA

5

5.1

32 Union Street

$6,595,000

37 Sankaty Head Road - Sconset, Nantucket MA

8

8.2

37 Sankaty Head Road

$26,850,000

View All Listings

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

Message (Optional)
Message

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.