14 Liberty Street


14 Liberty Street Nantucket

This classic Nantucket home offers a timeless and contemporary design full of charm, just steps from Main Street. With four floors of renovated living space, this historic home is nestled steps from some of Town's most sought after attractions. Renovated in 2017, the updated Coleman House offers six bedrooms across four floors of ample living space both indoors and out. This property has the ease and convenience of the location while still maintaining the feeling of being tucked away, thanks to the quiet nature of Liberty Street. The house boasts abundant fireplaces, original floors, and a bright and open floor plan.

First Floor

Entering through the timeless foyer is a private sitting room to the right that overlooks the street and has one of six fireplaces. This is a cozy sitting room but could also make for an excellent den or office. The rest of the first floor is an open concept layout designed with entertaining and gathering in mind. This space features an incredible gourmet kitchen with a working fireplace, dining space, and a sitting area. The kitchen is outfitted with top-of-the-line appliances and a large island to make entertaining effortless. Adjacent to the kitchen is the dining space and family room with another working fireplace. On this floor is also a pantry and powder room.

Second Floor

At the top of the stairs is a nook, perfect for a study or reading area. The master bedroom has large twelve-pane windows overlooking the street and an ensuite full bath with two separate marble sinks and a multi-head glass and tile shower. On this floor is another ensuite bedroom with a glass and tile tub/shower. The two bedrooms are adjoined by a comfortable sitting room with a full bath, previously used as a bedroom. All of the rooms are equipped with fireplaces.

Third Floor

Tucked away high above the street, the third floor is comprised of an ensuite bedroom accented with beadboard and original exposed beams as well as original floors. The bathroom has a large glass and tile walk-in shower with a rain showerhead.


The lower level features two bedrooms, a washer and dryer, a glass and marble built-in bar, a full-size wine fridge and ample storage space. Both bedrooms share a full bathroom with a tub/shower, connected through a hallway with a storage room at the end of it. The larger bedroom has a fireplace and exposed beams. The second bedroom is smaller yet bright and features an original beam inscribed in 1881.


$3,975,000 Asking price
6 Rooms
6 Bedrooms
5 Bathrooms

Photo Gallery



Representation By

Greg McKechnie avatar
Greg McKechnie

Email: greg@greatpointproperties.com

Mobile: 508-221-8866

Greg grew up in Malvern, Pennsylvania, where he attended the Haverford School before attending Trinity College in Hartford, Connecticut. A longtime summer resident, Greg moved to Nantucket full-time fifteen years ago. In addition to his substantial experience with Nantucket real estate sales, Greg is actively involved in the community. He is presently serving as Past President of the Board Directors for the Nantucket Boys and Girls Club, and Treasurer for the Board of Directors at the Linda Loring Foundation. When he is not working with customers, Greg enjoys spending time with his wife, Courtney, a personal trainer and Pilates instructor. Greg and Courtney welcomed their first child, Lyla Gray McKechnie, into the world on December 2, 2008, and their son, Beau Jameson McKechnie, joined the family on November 2, 2011. Greg enjoys early morning runs with his dogs Jack, an Irish Jack Russell, and Lucie, a rescue from Nantucket Safe Harbor, in Sanford Farm. He also enjoys many water-based activities including surfing, paddleboarding, open-water swimming, and fishing.

Alexa Coleman avatar
Alexa Coleman

Email: alexa@greatpointproperties.com

Mobile: 508.221.2776

Alexa grew up on the North Shore of Massachusetts and spent her summers on Nantucket.

She attended Saint Michael’s College in Colchester, Vermont, and studied Political Science and International Relations, Spanish, and Media Studies, and was a four year honors student-athlete competing with the NCAA Division II Saint Michael’s women’s lacrosse team.

After graduation, Alexa spent the summer on Nantucket nannying and working in the hospitality industry. She moved back to Boston for one winter where she worked as a Placement Manager at an au pair agency. She quickly realized how much she missed the island and came back to Nantucket the next summer to intern at Great Point Properties. Under the guidance of broker Laura Fletcher, Alexa learned the ins and outs of Nantucket’s Real Estate. She joined our team as a full time agent in November 2015 and permanently made Nantucket her home. She has since immersed herself in the island’s community. In 2015 she joined the Nantucket Student Lacrosse Board where she has successfully lead the charge to grow the women's lacrosse program on Island. She also coaches the youth program head coaching the U-13 girls team and assistant coaching the girls U-15 team.

Alexa is also highly involved with the Boys and Girls Club of Nantucket and will co-chair their annual fundraiser, The Tim Russert Summer Groove in August 2019.

Alexa is knowledgable and experienced when it comes to activities and hot spots on the island no matter what your interests are.  Alexa brings a unique perspective on island living and vacationing to clients and specializes in market research and rental investments. She works alongside principal broker, Edward Sanford to produce and write our market reports. Alexa loves being active and when she is not at her desk, she is an avid runner and yoga enthusiast. She loves skiing, traveling and spending time with her family in the Boston, Providence and Telluride areas.


Request More Info

Please fill out the form below if you would like additional information or would like to schedule a viewing for 14 Liberty Street

Preferred Method of Contact (required)

Call Agent