A Century on Nantucket: 100 Years on Milk Street

08/01/2025

Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket on one of the most prominent streets, 12 Milk Street stands as a testament to the island's architectural heritage. Built in the early 1800s, this Federal-style home features a period-accurate trim and original wide-plank floors, reflecting both its grandeur for its time and lasting authenticity.

Once the home of a first mate in a bustling whaling economy, the property has gracefully evolved over time with modern amenities and furniture while preserving its historic charm. Set on an oversized lot adorned with mature trees and flowering gardens, the main house and separate studio dwelling create a tranquil oasis- perfect for enjoying garden views from the deck or patio. 12 Milk Street remains a part of Nantucket's enduring narrative, preserving the island's classical architecture built from the wealth of whaling families.

Ownership History

12 Milk street carries centuries of history in its walls, including the story of one of Nantucket's founding families, the Starbuck family. This property has been the home of twenty-three different families since 1750.

Thomas Broadus Ⅲ - (2022-Current)

12 Milk Street LLC - (2012-2022)

Kenneth Logan - (2005-2012)

Marina Sutro - (1991-2005)

William Sledon - (1968-1991)

Norman Mack - (1967-1968)

Patricia Harris Johnson - (1963-1967)

Harry & Gilbert Bean - (1959-1963)

Frederick & Susan Fuller - (1925-1959)

Lydia & Arthur Cook (1902-1925)

Israel & Mary Swain - (1889-1902)

William Swain (1889)

Andrew & Lydia Gardner - (1866-1889) After Andrew Gardner's death in 1889, children sold at public auction.

William & Love Chadwick Jernegan - (1858-1866) Jernegan family moved in 1861, house was occupied by Alexander Chadwick and children until 1866.

Benjamin & Phebe Coffin Chase - (1840-1858)

Frederick & Lydia Macy - (1834-1840) Sold at public auction.

Barzillai and Mary Macy - (1821-1834) Cooper’s shop on premises 1834

Paul Macy - (1818-1821)

Coleman heirs - (1812-1818)

John & Ann Coleman - (1784-1812)

Tristram & Deborah Starbuck - (1772-1784)

Stanton heirs - (1750-1772)

Samuel & Sarah Stanton - (1737-1750)

Plans

Gallery

Read our other case studies: