10 Gay Street Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$2,499,000
Asking Price
$2,350,000
Selling Price
Sold
Market Status
8 beds
Bedrooms
9.1 beds
Bathrooms
4,212 beds
Square Footage

The Sherburne Inn represents a most attractive opportunity for the investor, as well as for the end-user. The investor will find an established, well-run, profitable, turn-key hostelry; something very difficult to find here on the island. The end-user will see the potential for conversion to a comfortable and stylish single family home. The location is optimal: steps from all that Nantucket Town has to offer, on a quiet, one way street. PROPERTY MAY BE DIVIDED IN TWO PER CH. 41 SEC. 81L OF MASS. GEN. LAWS.

First Floor

Steps to porch and entryway that is well above street level. Foyer,  Curved Stairway to 2nd floor, Guestroom, Lobby with Fireplace, Hallway to two more Guestrooms, Large Guest Suite. rear Stairway.

Second Floor

Sitting area, Guestroom, Parlor with Fireplace, two more Guestrooms, rear stairs and landing, Large Guestroom with private sun-porch. Attic Stairway.

Third Floor

Fully floored, stand-up Attic for Storage or expansion.

  • Selling Date 5/26/2015
  • Listed Date 8/22/2014
  • Days on Market 277
  • % To Listing Price 94
  • Total Rooms 15
  • Total Beds 8
  • Full Baths 9
  • Half Baths 1
  • Lot Size 0.103 acres
  • Year Built 1833
  • Zoning ROH
Listed on by Great Point Properties
10 Gay Street - Sales History
  • Selling date: 6/28/2021
    Selling price: $2,900,000
  • Selling date: 4/1/2008
    Selling price: $2,525,000
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about South Of Town

Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.

Learn more

Recommended for you

10 Evergreen Way

$450,000

4 beds
3.1 beds

44 Sankaty Road

$4,212,500

6/9/2026

DOM: 258

3 beds
4.0 beds

34 Pine Street

$2,325,000

6/8/2026

DOM: 288

5 beds
4.1 beds

10 Rudder Lane

$4,150,000

6/3/2026

DOM: 22

4 beds
3.0 beds

4 Eagle Lane

$2,945,000

6/1/2026

DOM: 0

3 beds
2.0 beds

6 Eagle Lane

$2,300,000

5/30/2026

DOM: 184

2 beds
2.0 beds

42 North Liberty Street

$2,650,000

5/29/2026

DOM: 26

7 Miacomet Avenue

$1,100,000

5/29/2026

DOM: 72

4 beds
2.1 beds

13 Eat Fire Spring Road

$3,800,594

5/29/2026

DOM: 56

2 beds
1.1 beds
880 sf beds

15 Old North Wharf

$3,800,000

5/22/2026

DOM: 0

3 beds
2.0 beds

4 Berkley Street

$1,925,000

5/21/2026

DOM: 136

8 beds
6.2 beds

4 Shawkemo Hills Lane

$10,000,000

5/20/2026

DOM: 222

22 Washington Avenue

$250,000

5/20/2026

DOM: 0

West of Town
 

74 Madaket Road

$2,875,000

5/20/2026

DOM: 160

4 beds
4.0 beds

87 Goldfinch Drive

$2,325,000

5/19/2026

DOM: 3

4 beds
3.1 beds

85R Orange Street

$3,000,000

5/19/2026

DOM: 247

3 beds
4.1 beds

11 Hydrangea Lane

$4,025,000

5/15/2026

DOM: 18

14 West Creek Road

$990,000

3 beds
2.1 beds

31 Flintlock Road

$2,595,000

5/11/2026

DOM: 90

11 Sesapana Road

$2,800,000

5/8/2026

DOM: 12

3 beds
3.1 beds

6 Arkansas Avenue

$1,995,000

5/7/2026

DOM: 116

3 beds
4.1 beds

57 Quidnet Road

$6,250,000

5/6/2026

DOM: 16

6 beds
6.2 beds

12 Correia Lane

$9,050,000

5/5/2026

DOM: 267

6 beds
7.1 beds

42 Main Street

$9,195,000

5/4/2026

DOM: 0

 
0.4 beds

17 Old South Road

$4,150,000

5/1/2026

DOM: 59

20 Nancy Ann Lane

$1,400,000

5/1/2026

DOM: 85

3 beds
3.1 beds

10B Park Circle

$1,050,000

4 beds
5.1 beds

10 Beach Grass Road

$2,800,000

4/29/2026

DOM: 86

3 beds
2.0 beds

5 Marble Way #2

$854,000

2 beds
2.0 beds
960 sf beds

68 Arkansas Avenue

$695,000

4 beds
2.2 beds

6 Harbor Terrace

$5,250,000

4/21/2026

DOM: 15

6 beds
5.1 beds

10 Doc Ryder Drive

$3,985,000

4/20/2026

DOM: 273

65B Surfside Road

$775,000

4/16/2026

DOM: 65

5 beds
4.2 beds

15 Skyline Drive

$4,111,500

4/16/2026

DOM: 158

12 Van Gilder Avenue

$1,557,000

West of Town
3 beds
0.1 beds

62 Madaket Road

$2,500,000

158 Madaket Road

$2,000,000

4/9/2026

DOM: 236

 
1.0 beds

78A Old South Road

$1,075,000

4 beds
4.0 beds

20 Evergreen Way

$2,820,000

4/7/2026

DOM: 212

34 Tennessee Avenue

$1,500,000

9 beds
5.0 beds

4 Boynton Lane

$1,812,500

5 beds
3.1 beds

26 Milk Street (Lot 1)

$3,700,000

3/31/2026

DOM: 103

4 beds
4.0 beds

25C Pine Street

$4,800,000

3/30/2026

DOM: 174

 
1.0 beds
960 sf beds

5 New Street

$855,000

6 beds
6.3 beds

111 Surfside Road

$10,250,000

6 beds
5.1 beds

10 Milk Street

$5,075,000

3/26/2026

DOM: 101

16 Bayberry Lane

$1,400,000

2 beds
2.1 beds

17B Old South Road

$930,000

3/24/2026

DOM: 2

4 beds
4.1 beds

4 Goose Cove Way

$3,700,000

3 beds
1.1 beds

20 Lyons Lane

$2,375,000

3/18/2026

DOM: 88

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.