10 Gay Street Nantucket, MA 02554

  • Overview
  • Property Details
  • Location
$3,495,000
Asking Price
$2,900,000
Selling Price
Sold
Market Status
10 beds
Bedrooms
9.1 beds
Bathrooms
4,212 beds
Square Footage

Dreaming of owning a B&B on Nantucket Island...wait no longer! The Sherburne Inn is currently being run as one of the top ranked B&Bs on the Island, but opportunity awaits a buyer who wants to turn it into a beautiful private residence. Perfectly located on a peaceful side street in Nantucket's downtown historic district. The Sherburne Inn is rich with history. Dating back to 1835, it was originally built as the headquarters for the Atlantic Silk company. Pride of ownership is evident throughout in respecting the historic details but offering modern amenities. The guest house features eight unique bright and airy guest rooms, each with private bath and central air. Guests also have access to two parlor rooms and ample outdoor seating. The innkeepers quarters are located in the bottom of the guest house, and feature an apartment with bath, large kitchen and additional space for staff. One car garage and 2 off street parking spots. Full financials available upon signing of an NDA.

First Floor

Front entry foyer immediately draws your eye to the details of the majestic staircase leading to the second floor. Continue through to the reception/parlor with fireplace and large utility closet. To the left of the entry is a twin guest room with private bath. This floor also features a queen guest room with bath and fireplace, smaller queen guest room with private bath and large king guestroom with private bath. Access to deck and outdoor seating area.

Second Floor

Climb the stairs to a parlor room with fireplace and second large utility closet. Additional quiet sitting/reading area. Two additional queen guest rooms with private baths, king guest room with private bath and king guest suite with private bath and small deck.

Third Floor

Attic storage

  • Selling Date 6/28/2021
  • Listed Date 8/27/2020
  • Days on Market 305
  • % To Listing Price 83
  • Total Rooms 15
  • Total Beds 10
  • Full Baths 9
  • Half Baths 1
  • Lot Size 0.1 acres
  • Year Built 1833
  • Zoning ROH
Listed on by William Raveis Nantucket
10 Gay Street - Sales History
  • Selling date: 5/26/2015
    Selling price: $2,350,000
  • Selling date: 4/1/2008
    Selling price: $2,525,000
nantucket sun icon

Location

What we like about South Of Town

Moments to Town, yet centrally located among conservation land and bike paths.

Learn more

Recommended for you

4 beds
2.0 beds

1 Dennis Drive

$2,000,000

5 beds
5.1 beds

15 Cottage Avenue

$6,800,000

4 beds
3.2 beds

6 Marion Avenue

$6,500,000

3/5/2026

DOM: 201

8 beds
6.2 beds

33 Pocomo Road

$16,800,000

3/2/2026

DOM: 34

4 beds
4.0 beds

50 Lovers Lane

$4,340,000

2/27/2026

DOM: 59

4 beds
3.2 beds

118 Eel Point Road

$5,550,000

2/25/2026

DOM: 1000

5 beds
2.0 beds

8 Macy Road

$1,700,000

2/20/2026

DOM: 37

6 beds
4.1 beds

22 Vestal Street

$5,100,000

2/20/2026

DOM: 193

5 beds
3.0 beds

37 Cliff Road

$8,141,000

 
3.2 beds

27 Fairgrounds Road

$4,200,000

2/17/2026

DOM: 125

5 Gray Avenue, Lot 178

$1,487,500

2/11/2026

DOM: 20

5 Gray Avenue, Lot 177

$1,487,500

2/11/2026

DOM: 20

6 beds
3.0 beds

51 North Liberty Street

$2,550,000

2/10/2026

DOM: 85

6 beds
6.0 beds

20 Pine Grove Road

$2,400,000

2/10/2026

DOM: 62

12A Greglen Avenue

$1,600,000

2/6/2026

DOM: 31

6 beds
4.2 beds

12 & 13 Shimmo Pond Road

$4,795,000

2/5/2026

DOM: 149

4 beds
2.0 beds

62 Nobadeer Avenue

$4,400,000

10 beds
9.3 beds

24 Flintlock Road

$9,750,000

2/3/2026

DOM: 59

5 beds
5.2 beds

36 West Chester Street

$7,300,000

1/30/2026

DOM: 134

3 beds
2.1 beds

51 Goldfinch Drive

$1,800,000

3 beds
2.1 beds

7 White Street

$3,095,000

1/21/2026

DOM: 153

12 Nonantum Avenue

$1,900,000

8 beds
6.0 beds

11 Cynthia Lane

$1,980,389

6 beds
2.0 beds

71 Cato Lane

$2,928,536

7 beds
3.1 beds

13 Cynthia Lane

$3,455,661

8 beds
6.0 beds

10 Green Meadows

$3,317,707

6 beds
4.0 beds

10R Green Meadows

$3,317,707

4 beds
5.1 beds

41A Cliff Road

$13,550,000

5 Upper Tawpawshaw Road

$5,850,000

1/15/2026

DOM: 150

36 Ridge Lane

$1,495,000

1/15/2026

DOM: 28

3 beds
2.0 beds

5 Altheas Lane

$1,650,000

1/14/2026

DOM: 29

7 beds
8.3 beds

51 Weweeder Avenue

$14,750,000

1/14/2026

DOM: 77

5 beds
4.1 beds

35 Pilgrim Road

$4,575,000

20 East Lincoln Avenue & 13 Cornish Court

$2,600,000

1/13/2026

DOM: 376

24 Meadow View Drive

$5,400,000

1/12/2026

DOM: 89

1 Pinkham Circle

$2,645,000

1/12/2026

DOM: 88

 
0.1 beds

40A Center Street

$3,010,000

2 beds
1.0 beds
984 sf beds

26 North Cambridge Street

$4,500,000

1/7/2026

DOM: 252

5 beds
5.0 beds

21.5 Hussey Street

$6,900,000

1/7/2026

DOM: 33

45 Millbrook Road

$2,500,000

1/7/2026

DOM: 206

9 beds
6.2 beds

9 Green Hollow Road

$3,850,000

1/6/2026

DOM: 542

3 beds
2.1 beds

21 Honeysuckle Drive

$306,500

7 beds
5.1 beds

160 Madaket Road

$3,675,000

1/5/2026

DOM: 192

Nautical flags of Nantucket

Questions? Let us reach out to you.

  • Message (Optional)

Or give us a call at (508) 228-2266

A real person will answer the phone Monday-Saturday 9am-5pm, and Sunday 10am-2pm.